Can my insurance company force me to use their shop in NY?
No. Under New York Insurance Law § 2610, an insurer providing collision or comprehensive coverage cannot require that repairs be made at a particular shop. You can have your vehicle repaired at the shop of your choice.
- It must tell you in writing: the insurer’s repair estimate must include a printed notice, in at least 12-point type, of your right to choose your shop.
- No unrequested recommendations: while processing your claim, the insurer may not recommend or suggest a particular shop unless you expressly ask. Claims involving only window glass are exempt from this rule and from the notice requirement.
- Still in force today: New York’s Department of Financial Services enforces the law as interpreted by the state’s highest court.
What Insurance Steering Sounds Like, and What NY Law Says
Steering is when an insurer pushes you toward a particular repair shop. These are common lines, checked against New York law.
| What you might hear | What New York law says | Source |
|---|---|---|
| “You need to take it to one of our shops.” | False. An insurer cannot require repairs at a particular place, shop, or concern. | § 2610(a) |
| “Here is the shop we recommend,” when you did not ask | Not allowed while processing your claim, unless you expressly requested a recommendation. | § 2610(b) |
| “Your car’s maker requires a certified shop, so go to this one.” | An insurer may tell you the manufacturer has a certified-shop requirement and suggest you contact the manufacturer, but cannot steer you to a particular shop without your request. | DFS opinion 04-06-03 |
| “Our appraiser handles everything with the shop.” | You can sign a form naming the DMV-registered shop you chose as your designated representative to negotiate the repair cost. | 11 NYCRR 216.7 |
Scroll sideways to see the full table on mobile.
New York’s Anti-Steering Law and How It Has Held Up
Insurers have challenged part of the law in court. The core protection, your right to choose, was never in question, and the limit on unrequested recommendations is still enforced.
| Year | What happened |
|---|---|
| 1973 | Insurance Law § 2610(a) enacted: insurers cannot require repairs at a particular shop. |
| 1974 | § 2610(b) added: insurers cannot recommend a particular shop unless the insured asks. |
| 2000 | A federal district court ruled § 2610(b), as applied to Allstate and GEICO, violated the First Amendment. |
| 2002 | On questions sent by the federal appeals court, New York’s Court of Appeals interpreted § 2610(b) to restrict recommendations about particular shops, not an insurer’s general promotion of its repair program. |
| 2003 | The federal court vacated its earlier ruling, and the Insurance Department confirmed § 2610(b) remains in effect and will be enforced consistent with the Court of Appeals’ interpretation. |
Sources: Insurance Law § 2610, Allstate Ins. Co. v. Serio (N.Y. Court of Appeals, 2002), and DFS Circular Letter No. 14 (2003).
What insurers can still do
Insurers can promote their repair programs in general, and they can recommend a shop if you ask them to. What § 2610(b) restricts is an insurer recommending a particular shop, unprompted, while processing your claim.
How to Choose an Auto Body Shop in New York
Since the choice is yours, these are the questions worth asking any shop before you authorize repairs.
Is it certified for your vehicle?
Many automakers certify shops to follow their repair procedures. Find a VIVE location certified by your manufacturer on the factory-certified page.
Will it deal with your insurer?
Ask whether the shop handles adjuster communication and supplements, and whether it can act as your designated representative.
Are its technicians trained?
Modern vehicles use advanced materials and safety sensors. Ask about ongoing training, such as VIVE’s technician training and I-CAR programs.
What does the warranty cover?
Ask how long repairs are guaranteed and who stands behind them, then get the terms in writing.
What to Do If You Feel Steered
1. Tell your insurer your choice
When you report the claim, say where you want the car repaired. You do not need the insurer’s approval of the shop.
2. Check the estimate notice
Your insurer’s estimate should include the printed § 2610 notice of your right to choose. Keep a copy.
3. Let your shop negotiate
Sign a designated representative form so your chosen shop can negotiate the repair cost directly with your insurer.
4. Report steering
If an insurer pressures you, file a complaint with the NY Department of Financial Services.
Resources: DFS guide to filing claims under your own policy and DFS complaint page.
Why Capital Region Drivers Choose VIVE Collision of Albany
We work with all major insurance carriers and handle communication with their adjusters, whether or not we are on an insurer’s list.
Factory certified
Audi Authorized Collision Repair, BMW Certified Collision Repair Center, Tesla Approved Collision Center, and VW Certified Repair Facility.
Claims start to finish
Free estimates, insurance claims handled from start to finish, on-site rental vehicles, and towing arrangements.
Backed for life
Every repair carries a lifetime warranty, and repair financing is available for out-of-pocket costs.
Local to the Capital Region
Serving Albany, Colonie, Latham, and Guilderland from 808 Central Ave. See our auto body repair services in Albany.
Choose VIVE Collision of Albany
Tell your insurer you are using VIVE Collision of Albany, then send photos for a free estimate. We will handle it from there.
808 Central Ave, Albany, NY 12206 | Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM, Sat 9 AM–12 PM
Frequently Asked Questions
choosing-your-shop