OEM vs Aftermarket: What You Need to Know

Includes New Jersey Insurance Rules
Sources: NJ Regulations, AAA, Automakers
Mt Holly, NJ

OEM vs Aftermarket Parts: What You Need to Know

Your collision estimate may list factory (OEM) parts, aftermarket parts, or both. Here is how they compare on fit, testing, warranty, cost, and safety-system compatibility, plus the New Jersey rules insurers must follow when they write an estimate with non-OEM parts.

Are aftermarket auto parts as good as OEM?

It depends on the part and whether it is certified. OEM parts are made by or for your vehicle’s manufacturer. Aftermarket parts come from other companies, and their quality varies. Some are independently tested against the OEM part; many are not.

  • Cosmetic panels such as fenders, hoods, and bumper covers are where certified aftermarket parts are most common. CAPA certification verifies that tested samples match the fit, finish, and performance of the automaker’s part.
  • Safety-system parts are where automakers push back hardest. Honda, Toyota, and Ford all warn that non-original windshields can keep the forward camera from working properly.
  • In New Jersey, an insurer cannot require aftermarket parts unless they are warranted by the maker and at least equal to OEM in fit, quality, and performance, and it must identify them on your estimate.

OEM vs Aftermarket Parts: Side-by-Side Comparison

“Aftermarket” covers a wide range of quality. The biggest difference is between aftermarket parts that are independently certified and those that are not.

OEM (original equipment)Certified aftermarket (CAPA)Uncertified aftermarket
Who makes itThe vehicle manufacturer or a company licensed to make parts for itAn independent manufacturer whose part samples pass third-party CAPA testingAn independent manufacturer, with no independent certification
How quality is checkedBuilt to the automaker’s own specificationsRepresentative samples are tested against the automaker’s service part for fit, finish, and performanceNo outside testing; quality depends on the maker
How to identify itAutomaker branding and part numberYellow two-part CAPA seal with a unique number and bar codeNo CAPA seal
Rules when an NJ insurer requires itCovered by the automaker’s parts warrantyParts certified by an independent testing lab as like kind and quality are deemed to meet New Jersey’s standardMust be warranted by the maker for a reasonable duration and coverage and equal OEM in fit, quality, and performance
Typical costHighestLower; the aftermarket parts industry says 25–60% less than OEMLower; the aftermarket parts industry says 25–60% less than OEM
Safety-system parts (cameras, radar areas)What automakers specify; several require OEM glass for camera-equipped windshieldsCAPA has standards for windshields, cameras, and sensors, but automaker positions still applyAutomakers warn of camera aiming problems and radar interference

Scroll sideways to see the full table on mobile. Sources: CAPA, N.J.A.C. 11:2-17.10, and the cost range cited by the Auto Body Parts Association in Repairer Driven News.

Where the Part Choice Matters Most

Not every part carries the same risk. These are the areas where automakers and testing groups have raised the most specific concerns.

Windshields with cameras

Honda states that anything other than an original-equipment windshield can stop the forward camera from aiming properly. Ford does not approve aftermarket windshields, and Toyota warns aftermarket glass may lack camera brackets or have a border that blocks the camera’s view. Read the automaker statements in AAA’s report.

Grilles and emblems over radar

On some Honda and Acura models, the radar for collision-mitigation braking sees through the grille molding or emblem. Honda says these parts are specially designed to prevent radar interference, and the wrong part turns on a warning light and sets a fault code. See Honda’s position statement.

Bumper reinforcements and energy absorbers

These hidden parts manage crash energy. CAPA created a dedicated bumper-parts standard and reported that an uncertified aftermarket energy absorber for the 2006–2009 Ford Fusion was made of a different plastic than labeled and broke into pieces in a crash test, unlike the Ford part. Read the BodyShop Business report.

Cosmetic body panels

Fenders, hoods, and bumper covers are the most common aftermarket crash parts. CAPA has separate standards for metal and plastic exterior parts, so asking for certified parts is a practical way to screen quality.

New Jersey Rules for Aftermarket Parts on Insurance Estimates

New Jersey’s unfair claims settlement rules (N.J.A.C. 11:2-17.10) set the conditions an insurer must meet when it specifies aftermarket parts for your repair. The same rules bar an insurer from requiring a particular repair shop as a condition of payment, unless it is exercising a policy right to repair the vehicle itself.

  1. An insurer cannot require aftermarket parts unless the maker warrants them for a reasonable duration and coverage.
  2. The parts must be at least equal in like kind and quality to OEM replacement parts in fit, quality, and performance.
  3. Parts certified by an independent testing laboratory as like kind and quality are deemed to meet that standard.
  4. An insurer that specifies aftermarket parts must pay for any modifications needed to make them work in the repair.
  5. The insurer must give you a written notice, on or attached to the estimate, that the estimate is based on parts not made by the original manufacturer.
  6. Every aftermarket part installed on your vehicle must be clearly identified on the estimate.
  7. Aftermarket parts must carry permanent identification of their manufacturer, visible after installation where possible.

Source: N.J.A.C. 11:2-17.10(a)6 and 10–13.

New Jersey does not require OEM-only repairs

In 2012, a New Jersey body shop petitioned the Department of Banking and Insurance to tighten these aftermarket parts rules. The Department declined, citing possible unintended consequences such as higher costs, so the standard remains “like kind and quality,” not OEM-only. Read the DOBI decision.

What Are the Best Collision Parts for Your Repair?

The best part depends on what it does. Use this guide to decide where to insist on OEM and where a certified alternative is a reasonable option.

Part on your estimateBest choiceWhy it matters
Windshield on a vehicle with a forward cameraFollow the automaker’s glass position; Honda, Toyota, and Ford all favor original-equipment glassCamera aiming and calibration depend on the glass and its brackets
Grille, emblem, or bumper area in front of a radar sensorUse the part the automaker specifies for radar-equipped modelsSome parts are designed to let radar pass through without interference
Bumper reinforcement or energy absorberOEM, or a part certified to CAPA’s bumper standardThese parts manage crash energy; uncertified versions have failed comparison testing
Fender, hood, or bumper cover on an older vehicleOEM or CAPA-certified aftermarketCertified parts are tested for fit and finish against the automaker’s part
Any uncertified aftermarket part on your estimateAsk for the maker’s warranty termsNew Jersey requires insurer-specified aftermarket parts to be warranted by the maker

Questions to ask about your estimate

  • Which parts are OEM, and which are aftermarket, recycled, or remanufactured?
  • Who makes each aftermarket part, and is it CAPA-certified?
  • Does the automaker have a position statement on any of these parts, especially glass and parts near cameras or radar?
  • What warranty covers each part, and who honors it?

How Lamon Auto Body Approaches Parts

Lamon Auto Body handles insurance claims from start to finish for drivers throughout Mt Holly and Burlington County, and our estimators can walk you through which parts on your estimate are OEM and which are not.

Insurance claims start to finish

Free estimates, full insurance claim handling, and a lifetime warranty on our work. See the Lamon Auto Body location page.

Glass, dents, and heavy-duty trucks

Automotive glass replacement, paintless dent repair, towing arrangements, and heavy-duty truck repair, plus repair financing.

Backed by VIVE Collision

Lamon joined VIVE Collision in 2025, adding a network that invests in continuous technician training and modern safety-system repair. Learn about our ADAS repair process.

Have Questions About the Parts on Your Estimate?

Schedule an inspection at our Mt Holly shop and bring your insurance estimate. We will walk you through which parts are OEM, which are not, and what your automaker recommends.

289 Rancocas Rd, Mt Holly, NJ 08060  |  Mon–Fri 8 AM–5 PM

Frequently Asked Questions

Are aftermarket auto parts as good as OEM?

Some are and some are not. CAPA-certified aftermarket parts are tested against the automaker’s part for fit, finish, and performance, while uncertified parts have no independent testing. For parts tied to safety systems, such as camera-equipped windshields and grilles in front of radar, automakers including Honda, Toyota, and Ford warn that non-original parts can cause those systems to work improperly.

Can my insurance company use aftermarket parts in New Jersey?

Yes, with conditions. Under N.J.A.C. 11:2-17.10, the parts must be warranted by the maker and at least equal in like kind and quality to OEM parts in fit, quality, and performance. The insurer must disclose in writing that the estimate uses non-OEM parts, identify each one, and pay for any modifications needed to make them fit.

What does CAPA certified mean?

CAPA, the Certified Automotive Parts Association, is an independent nonprofit that certifies aftermarket crash parts. Representative samples are tested by a third-party lab against the automaker’s service part, and certified parts carry a yellow two-part seal with a unique number and bar code. In New Jersey, parts certified by an independent testing laboratory as like kind and quality are deemed to meet the state’s standard.

Does New Jersey require OEM parts?

No. New Jersey allows insurers to specify aftermarket parts that meet its like kind and quality standard. In 2012 the Department of Banking and Insurance declined a petition to tighten the rules, citing possible unintended consequences such as higher costs.

Which parts should always be OEM?

Follow the automaker’s position statements for your vehicle. Honda, Toyota, and Ford all favor original-equipment windshields on vehicles with a forward camera, and Honda says grille parts in front of its radar sensors are specially designed to prevent interference.

How much cheaper are aftermarket parts?

The Auto Body Parts Association, which represents aftermarket distributors, says aftermarket parts are typically priced 25 to 60 percent lower than OEM. Actual savings depend on the part, the vehicle, and whether extra labor is needed to make the part fit.

URL Path Slug: oem-vs-aftermarket